Skip to main content

Articles

Sophisticated Pitch, Nonexistent Benefit: The Due Diligence Lesson of Bunel

Date

November 18, 2026

Read Time

2 minutes

Share


An October LP article about leveraged long-short ETF strategies designed to create or accelerate tax-loss harvesting opportunities focused on how those approaches are typically offered to high-net-worth investors through established investment banks, investment advisors, and brokers. Although there may be legitimate support for such strategies, their aggressiveness can invite heightened IRS attention.

A recently filed lawsuit illustrates a very different risk around aggressive strategies: a tax strategy that allegedly had no legitimate foundation in Federal tax law at all. Bunel v. E3 Consultants Group, LLC arose from the nationwide marketing and sale of purported sovereign tribal tax credits associated with Native American tribal programs. According to the class action complaint, E3 Consultants Group and related entities represented the credits as a legitimate means of substantially reducing Federal income tax obligations. The complaint alleges that more than 100 taxpayers collectively paid E3 between $30 million and $60 million for the purported credits. Taxpayers who subsequently claimed the benefits were met with IRS disallowances, leaving them exposed to back taxes, penalties, and interest.

Cases like Bunel are tempting to write off as obvious scams — something a sophisticated investor or advisor should readily spot. That understates the problem. Questionable tax products can be packaged and promoted with considerable sophistication, and even experienced investment advisors can be persuaded by the sales pitch and, in turn, introduce the strategy to their own clients. More importantly, the boundary between an aggressive but supportable tax position and one that crosses the line is not always apparent at the outset.

The IRS’s listed transactions provide a useful point of reference. The list, which currently contains 36 transactions, is not primarily a catalog of imaginary tax benefits. Rather, it includes the kinds of sophisticated transactions that clients may encounter through friends, fellow investors, advisors, or others in their financial circles. Some arrive accompanied by tax opinions that can create an additional sense of security without necessarily resolving the underlying tax risk.

An allegedly nonexistent benefit such as the sovereign tribal tax credits at issue in Bunel presents a related challenge. A scarcity of readily available information, rather than prompting skepticism, may be incorporated into the promoter’s pitch: The opportunity is supposedly obscure because it is known only to a select group of wealthy or sophisticated taxpayers. Exclusivity, complexity, and an impressive presentation are no substitutes for determining whether the claimed tax benefit actually exists and whether the proposed transaction is supported by the law.

When the promised income-tax savings are substantial, discretion and due diligence remain indispensable.

Questions about a purported tax benefit related to a proposed transaction? Reach out to Michael Tuchman or another member of LP’s Tax Planning Group.


Filed under: Corporate, Tax Planning

October 14, 2026

Tax-Efficient Investment Products Continue to Attract Capital and Regulatory Attention

Read More